Red Handed

Source: The New Games Book

Everyone forms a circle, and one person, chosen as IT, stands in the centre. While IT closes their eyes, the other players pass a small object from person to person.

IT signals and opens their eyes, and attempts to guess who is holding the object. They guess by tapping a player's fist. If it's empty, they move on.

Players are allowed to (even encouraged to) continue passing the object between players while IT is guessing.

If a player is caught with the object, they become the next IT.